The quota system, very basically is saying x amount of people from each race should be let into university.
Our teacher was saying that it is more fair to have the quota system when people are applying to university, as because of Apartheid, we need to improve the conditions for the previously disadvantaged. During Apartheid, only certain races were allowed to go to certain schools, so you ended up having "black" schools and "white" schools etc. She also said that we need to make sure we don't have a case of the poor staying poor, and the rich getting richer.
I strongly disagree because of the following:
- This year marks the 18th anniversary of the 1994 elections, which were the first free and fair. Because of this, this years matriculants would not have been affected by apartheid (even if they have failed a few times, as you only start school at 7 years of age.)
- Even with the quota system, the universities are still going to choose the students with the best possible chances of not dropping out, so even if there are mixed races, they will choose not the previously disadvantaged people of colour, but the ones who ended up going to private schools anyway.
- Universities should pick students based on their ability, not the colour of their skin. If I got a better mark than an indian, for instance, but a lower mark than another white, then the Indian would get in and I wouldn't.
- The more we make these provisions, the more we remind ourselves of our past, as well as racial differences. Yes. A terrible thing happened in our country. Yes, it was bad and people suffered. But that all stopped 18 years ago. We need to move forward.
- There are only so many spots for each career. Even if we qualify 10 000 lawyers a year, they won't all end up having jobs. We still need unskilled labour in this country.
- Our teacher was saying that the people of colour have not had the same learning oppurtunities as us, and they need to have the same going forward. But if they haven't had the proper primary and secondary schooling, they will battle a lot with university and end up dropping out anyway. So what will the universities do? Lower the standard of education, as they've done with schools, and then eventually our degrees won't be recognised by universities overseas.




































